Records of the Society of Teachers Opposed to Physical Punishment (STOPP)

This material is held atInstitute of Education Library and Archives, University College London

Scope and Content

Comprises records of the Society including:

Minutes of meetings

Membership records

Correspondence and papers regarding the general administration of the group including Finance and publicity

Correspondence with Local Education Authorities regarding the use of corporal punishment in schools around the UK

Lobbying papers - largely comprising correspondence with teaching unions and MPs leading up to the Education (Corporal Punishment) Bill vote in 1986

Publications and information collated by STOPP as part of their research

Papers regarding surveys into the use of corporal punishment at both state and independent schools

Correspondence and papers regarding cases of coporal punishment taken to the European Court of Human Rights

Letters to the press, mainly written by STOPP's Education Secretary Tom Scott

Case files (CLOSED)

STOPP publications including newsletters

Press notices written by STOPP

Audio-visual material

Artifacts - canes, tawses and paddles

Administrative / Biographical History

Founded in 1968, the Society of Teachers Opposed to Physical Punishment (STOPP) was a pressure group which campaigned for the abolition of corporal punishment in schools and other institutions in the United Kingdom.

It lobbied government officials, parliament, the churches, local education authorities, unions teachers' organisations and other bodies, wrote constantly to the press and published surveys and reports. It also investigated individual cases and supported families taking cases to the European Court of Human Rights. After corporal punishment was abolished in all state-supported education in the UK in 1986, the Society wound up its affairs. The Children's Legal Centre carried on its remaining casework and the residue of its funds were transferred to the group End Physical Punishment of Children (EPOCH).

Brief history of the corporal punishment in schools 1967-1987

1967 - the Plowden Report recommends the abolition of corporal punishment.

1968 - the Labour government issues Circular 1/68 stating schools should use corporal punishment less frequently.

1970-1974 - Conservative government states policies on corporal punishment should be decided on a local level by the Local Education Authorities (LEAs).

1976 - MP David Canavan brings a Private Members Bill calling for abolition; it is defeated 181 votes to 120.

1976 - Mrs Campbell and Mrs Cosans apply to the European Commission for their cases to be heard by the European Court of Human Rights

1977 - the Labour government begins consultation with the unions on the subject (most unions, at this point were in support of retaining corporal punishment)

1979/80 - both the Labour and Liberal parties adopt a pro-abolition stance

July 1981 - Labour leader Neil Kinnock (Shadow Education Secretary) states a Labour government would introduce legislation to ban corporal punishment

February 1981 the Inner London Education Authority (ILEA) bans the use of corporal punishment in all its schools

February 1982 - Campbell and Cosans versus UK judgment states UK parents should have the right to refuse corporal punishment as a form of discipline for their child(ren)

April 1982 - National Union of Teachers (NUT) adopts a pro-abolition stance

July 1982 - Assistant Masters and Mistresses Association (AMMA) adopts a pro-abolition stance

July 1983 - Department of Education and Science (DES) issues a consultation paper in response to the Campbell and Cosans judgment

1985 - Education (Corporal Punishment) Bill is introduced proposing a two-tier system and is opposed by the House of Lords

22 July 1986 - Education (No 2) Bill is passed abolishing the use of corporal punishment in state schools

November 1986 - the Education (No 2) Act becomes law

15th August 1987 - the use of corporal punishment in state schools becomes illegal

Campbell and Cosans case to the passing of the Education (No 2) Act 1986

In 1976 two Scottish mothers, Jane Cosans and Grace Campbell applied to the European Commission for their cases to be heard by the European Court of Human Rights. Mrs Campbell was the mother of a primary school aged child. Although her child had never received corporal punishment the local Council had refused her request that they guarantee her child was never caned. Mrs Cosans was the mother of a secondary school pupil who had refused to be caned (with his parents' support). The response from the local council was to suspend the boy from school until he ceased to be of compulsory school age.

The case claimed the use of corporal punishment in schools was contrary to Article 3 of the European Court of Human Rights stating that 'none shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment' and Article 2 that 'no person shall be denied the right to education'. In 1980 the Commission ruled that although Article 2 applied in this case, Article 3 did not. The case was heard by the Court in 1982, and the judgment, made on 25th February 1982, ruled British parents must have the right to refuse that corporal punishment be used to discipline their children in state schools.

In July 1983 the Department of Education and Science (DES) finally published a consultation document in response to the judgment but little action was taken until the introduction of the Education (Corporal Punishment) Bill 1985. Devised by Sir Keith Joseph (Secretary of State for Education), who opposed an outright ban, the Bill created two classes of pupil: those pupils who could receive physical punishment; and those who could not (depending on the personal view of their parents). The Bill received a lot of criticism - mainly that two pupils could receive different punishment for the same misdemeanour. The Bill was opposed by the House of Lords by a majority of four (108 to 104) and was withdrawn by the government a few weeks later. Within weeks a number of Local Education Authorities banned the use of corporal punishment in their schools.

In 1986 the government introduced the Education (No 2) Bill. When it was returned to the Commons from the Lords an abolitionist clause had been attached. Popular pressure meant the government allowed MPs a free vote in the Commons. After a debate in the House of Commons that lasted 3 hours and 40 minutes MPs approved the Lords amendment by a single vote (231-230). The 1986 Education Act which abolished the use of corporal punishment in state schools became law on 7th November 1986. Corporal punishment itself was banned from 15th August 1987.

Access Information

Restricted access

Due to the sensitive content of this collection many files are either closed under Section 33 of the Data Protection Act 1998 or access to readers is restricted. Other files are open. Please see file level descriptions, or contact the archives, for further information

Closed files

If the file has been closed under Section 33 of the Data Protection Act 1998 an assumed lifespan of 100 years has been applied. Access will be only granted to the data subject(s). No other access will be permitted.

Restricted Access:

Some files marked as 'Restricted Access' will only be made available to readers once they have signed the Data Protection Special Undertaking Form agreeing to anonymise any personal data in the file. Other material will be redacted before access is granted.

PLEASE NOTE:

If you require access to any files marked 'restricted access' the Archives will require TWO WEEKS notice prior to your visit to process your request. Please contact the archives with a full list of the files you would like to consult.

Acquisition Information

Transferred to the Institute of Education Archives in 1992

Other Finding Aids

Catalogued

Conditions Governing Use

A reader wishing to publish any quotation of information, including pictorial, derived from any archive material must apply in writing, in the first instance, for prior permission from the Archivist or other appropriate person(s) as indicated by the Archivist.

Custodial History

The collection was managed by the STOPP Committee and was transferred to the Institute of Education Archives in 1992 after the Society was disbanded.

Related Material

The library holds a number of STOPP publications.